Sunday, March 29, 2009
Teaching Ballads in the English Classroom
As we all know that youngsters nowadays listen to music much more than people of other ages, we can safely presume that they are highly likely exposed to songs with certain ideologies most of the time.
The issue of the ostensibility of an egalitarian society in terms of the genders has always been widely & actively debated by both genders over the decades. Some women have argued that men have been constantly perpetuating patriarchalism, thus, refusing to give equal rights to women. Whether this is accurate is not on focus in this entry. I, however, would like to argue that there are women out there who are actually exacerbating the current situation by reinforcing ideologies, specifically on how women may not be able to survive without men, or, that women are still deemed inferior to men in terms of social status.
With the above thesis, I would like to zoom into ballads sung by female singers. Let me take 3 ballads as examples:
1. “Lost Without You” by Delta Goodrem
2. “Midnight Train to Georgia” by Jasmine Trias
3. “All Around the World” by Coco Lee
Looking at the lyrics of the 1st ballad, “Lost Without You” sung by Delta Goodrem, one will see how the singer describes herself as being “stubborn”, “a little righteous and too proud”, & “never giving in”. Based on the aforesaid descriptions, we see that righteousness &”never giving in” (in other words, “persistence”), which are normally deemed as good qualities in an individual, are deemed as negative qualities in a woman, as there is a sense of self-deprecation from the singer since she mixes these qualities with other negative qualities, like, “stubborn” & “too proud”. In this sense, it seems as if women are not supposed to be righteous & persistent before men.
As we move into the chorus of the ballad, the singer further depicts herself as a weak individual as the lyrics go,
All I know is I’m lost without you
I’m not gonna lie
How am I gonna be strong without you
I need you by my side
If we ever said we’ll never be together
and we ended with goodbye
Don’t know what I’d do
I’m lost without you.
The singer then continues in the next stanza to reinforce her weakness,
I keep trying to find my way
but all I know is
I'm lost without you
I keep trying to face the day
Lost without you.
The 2 stanzas above tell readers how the singer is “lost” when her lover is not with her. She seems to have lost control in every aspect – physically, mentally, & emotionally – as the lyrics state that she doesn’t know how to be strong, & that she has problem trying to find her way. It seems as if she couldn’t think straight anymore, as the lyrics state, “all I know is I’m lost without you”. All in all, she is a total wreck with no sense of direction in her thinking, behaviour, & feeling. This shows how she cannot survive being alone.
The 2nd ballad, “Midnight Train to Georgia” performed by Jasmine Trias, talks about the departure of a man & how the woman would “rather live in his world than without him in [her own]”. Once again, we see how the woman is willing to sacrifice her own “world” just so she could be with the man she loves. It seems she is unable to get the man to be in her “world” if one is to think about it in this angle.
The last example, “All Around the World” sung by Coco Lee, talks about the singer being too busy to spend enough time with her lover due to her commitment as a singer, which requires her to travel constantly.
From some parts of the lyrics, one can gather that this woman can be considered to be possessing some power/influence, for she can be heard on the radio & seen on TV, as the lyrics state,
All around the world, Hear me on the radio
Catch me on a TV show
The assumption of her power/influence can be made, as one of the elements in deciding Forbes’ most power/influential celebrities is radio & TV exposure.
Nonetheless, despite this woman being one who holds certain degree of power/influence, she says things like, “Forever I'll be your girl”. From this, one sees that, firstly, she belongs to another person instead of herself; and secondly, the description of herself as a “girl” belittles her status as opposed to her lover's. Thus, we see how a woman like her, who possesses a certain amount of power, is still seen as someone else’s property and of an inferior status.
Having analysed the 3 ballads, let me touch on the 3 different knowledge which are to be employed for teachers to teach students to see the above ideology – informal knowledge, systematic knowledge, & transformative knowledge.
In terms of informal knowledge, teachers can get students to think of songs, which they know of, that talk about boy-girl relationships. As mentioned earlier, songs are part of the popular culture, & students are presumed to listen to a significant amount of pop music, thus, students should be familiar with this genre of text.
Next, systematic knowledge requires students to analyse the lyrics of the songs, as shown above, to suss out the ideology embedded in the songs. Students are expected to pick out words or phrases which provide evidence to any claim they make. In addition, students are also to think about the gender of the singer. The tune & melody of the song is also crucial in determining the mood of the singer’s voice. These are essential aspects to delve into.
Lastly, transformative knowledge will see students thinking of ways to challenge/resist the ideology that has been uncovered – in this case, the perpetuation of women’s inferiority by women. This can be done by generating songs which promote & celebrate women’s independence, & their ability to survive without the help of anyone. Songs like,
1. “I Belong To Me” by Jessica Simpson
2. “Independent Women” by Destiny’s Child
3. “Love Don’t Cost A Thing” by Jennifer Lopez
4. “Can’t Hold Us Down” & “Fighter” by Christina Aguilera
will give weights to contest the perpetuated ideology.
With such a focus of study going on, students will be rendered to think critically & analytically & realise the prevalence of the permeation of ideologies in an ostensibly entertaining text (songs). Furthermore, students will also get to see the various ways to counter these ideologies.
Motivating students to engage in such a study should not be an issue as pop music is one that students generally can relate to due to their frequent exposure to it, hence, its feasibility should not be deemed as hitting a rock with an egg.
Thursday, March 19, 2009
Words may not be Playing the role as a Second Fiddle Afterall
The above is made palpable as Lewitt made an observation of two students interacting with a multimodal text that teaches the students the scientific process of the transformation of ‘liquid to solid’. The students were apparently oblivious to the linguistic text (“liquid to solid) that was stated in the screen they were looking at, & they were clueless about what they seeing at the centre of the screen. In other words, they had no idea what they were looking at even when there were linguistic texts that states ‘liquid to solid’ at one part of the screen. This, Lewitt comments, shows how “[s]tudents often privilege one mode over another when they read multimodal texts. In this case, the visual mode is privileged over the linguistic one.
Aside from the aforesaid, Lewitt also remarks that linguistic texts are seemingly used for minor purposes nowadays as they are often used for labelling. I would say this might be so when we are talking about multimodal texts which are catered for texts which are not very “academic”. In this case, “academic” refers to texts which are of tertiary level and higher. Think of the innumerable canons there are in the repertoire areas of studies in the world – Law, Literature, Business, Philosophy, Psychology, Anthology, Anthropology, amongst others – & we will realise that most of the contents in these canons are made up of a mostly words, rather than any other modes. So, if we consider this fact, we will probably see that words are still very much the most utilised, desired and respected mode when it comes to texts at the higher level of the literary world.
I suppose if the other modes are looming around in the higher level of the literary world, it would be due to the areas of studies which require them, such as Music, Art, Visual Art, and the likes. Other than that, canons are usually dominated by words.
To put it crudely, and not to sound condescending at the same time, any other modes, other than words, may be considered, by some, to be meant for amateur readers.
Just to lay a disclaimer in case I get lambasted for making the above statement, I am writing this as an observer; not an advocate. So, I do not endorse everything I state in this entry. These are just observations.
Moving on to the implications for the pedagogic aspect, I suggest that teachers should inform students right from the beginning that words are still very much desired and respected as one moves higher in the academic realm. This is to get students mentally and physically prepared that they might be in contact with more words and less images as they progress academically. This is also in accordance to what Lewitt states in his article that it seems there is this pattern of the reduction in the amount of images as one progresses higher academically. Thus, we can try to accustom students to this pattern by reducing the amount of images and presenting them with more words as the time goes. This, I think, will be beneficial to them in time to come.
Sunday, March 15, 2009
In Response to Jennifer Tan's & Pippa Stein's Articles
After reading the 2 readings written by Jennifer Tan, as well as Pippa Stein, I generated my own little statement regarding my take on meaning-making – meaning-making is a process which is all-encompassing as it involves one’s culture, physical behaviour, mentality, creativity, and sensory.
Looking at the statement above, I think the writers’ stance on the pedagogical aspect would be to incorporate all of the aforesaid elements to help students establish their sense of “selves” as well as “identities”.
Something interesting, at least to me, was raised while we were discussing what the students in the DUSTY programme were doing. It is in relation to how some of the words these people use may be incomprehensible to people who do not understand their culture & way of using the English language, especially when there are so many slangs in theirs. Let us just say that everyone is encouraged to involve the above elements to (re)present themselves not only to the world, but also to their ownselves, but how will the world be able to see what these people are trying to (re)present themselves if the world does not even get the meaning of some of the way they express themselves through these elements?
One of my course mates, Syazwani (if I recall correctly), remarked that we do not need to understand, say, the linguistic elements of these people because we will still be able to see what these people are trying to express through other elements, like, their body language & facial expressions, for examples. Hearing that, I actually did agree with that. When I was pondering over it at home, however, I thought about the theory of relativism. To put relativism simply, I’ll use this saying to illustrate its definition – “One man’s meat is another man’s poison”. How does this link to the issue above? Let us have a look at the followings.
There’re many languages existing around the world currently, even though many have “died” over the millennium. Thus, language might already, in itself, be a source of “hindrance” when it comes to using it to bridge understanding between people. Even when two people are using English, do note that there’re many Englishes in the world too – Singapore English, British English, American English, and tonnes more! If I say “Porridge”, I mean congee as many Singaporeans use them interchangeably; but I believe the British would think of “Porridge” as “Oats” as that is what is known as Scottish porridge.
In terms of body gestures or languages, from the top of my mind with what I can think of, a thumb’s up in many countries implies “good”, “okay”, “yes”, and so on. These signifieds are not shared in either some parts of
In terms of culture, just to quote an example from Stein’s article, the Americans deem it respectful when conversing with one another by looking at each other in the eyes, but this is considered rude in
Looking at the 3 examples of relativism in 3 different aspects, how are we sure that what we intend to convey about ourselves to others are received in the way we intend to? Don’t you think every element is actually pretty much contextual? There is really not much everyone in the world share in common.
To answer the above issue, I suggest that we should all make an effort to try to our utmost to immerse ourselves, if not at least know a thing or two, into the cultures & lives of people we are not really familiar with. In addition, there should be no assumption made of anything we see, hear, smell, feel, & touch. Ask & clarify!
Yes, the suggestions I made may seem tedious as we might have to go to a huge extend to inquire about every single thing, but do note that nobody says this was going to be easy right from the start!
I read parts of the journal written by Captain John Smith, who is a real person (not just a fictitious character from the cartoon “Pocahontas”), & in it, he actually talked about immersing oneself to the culture of others in order to really know the people. It was only in the later stage that he came to a realisation that the Native Americans should not be considered as savages for they share numerous disparities in many aspects when compared with people of his own country.
I would like to emphasise that when we see the people in the DUSTY videos, we think we know what they are trying to express, but take a minute to think about whether we are interpreting everything we see of the video based on our own culture? Are our interpretations accurate if that is the case? Is it not important to know the author’s culture before generating any sort of interpretation of what we witness of them? This is just food for thought.
Thursday, March 5, 2009
Getting Students to Resist Discrimination & Discover Their 'Real Selves'
Jane Elliot Video Clip Part 2
When doing the presentation slides for my group’s presentation this week on using multimodal artefact to represent the videographer’s “true identity”, some issues struck me. One of which is the question on how do we, as teachers, get students to successfully recognise their “true selves” when they are made to believe they are of certain “selves/identities” based on the general society’s point of view?
Simply put, since the day an individual is borne, the individual has been subjected to a particular identity. As seen from the video of what Elliot did to her class of students with blue and brown eyes, we cannot help but see that students, who possess minds that are fresh and young, buy into whatever people say about them easily. As such, they internalise what is said of them and actually believe that they are what is said of them by others. As a result, they believe that they are of a certain “selves” which are given by the society. With such a phenomenon occurring, one cannot help but wonder how is it possible to get each student to see himself/herself as how they really are in person instead of how they are perceived by the society.
Let me draw a line between the definition of “identity” and “self” as they are not to be used interchangeably – “Identity” is imparted by others; while “self” is given by the person himself/herself. For instance, A male child may see himself as a girl, thus, he has defined his own “self”. However, due to his physicality which is of a boy, the people around him would identify him as a boy. From this, we see that the child’s “self” is a girl because this is what he has thought of himself as; but his identity is that of a boy because his identity is given by the people around him.
To me, it may be a tough road ahead if we are to make students see themselves as what they would see themselves as rather than what the society see them as. The reason is very simple. If one is to declare oneself as possessing a certain identity, one will have to get others to agree with one in order to successfully “possess” that certain identity. Let me give you an example – I can say that I am a girl. In fact, I can keep telling myself and everyone that. However, if nobody buys into this idea that I am a girl, I will forever be identified as being a boy. So, what is the point of me identifying myself as a girl when no one, other than myself, believes so? Hence, in this sense, we see that a person’s identity is very much bestowed by not the person himself/herself, but others.
Riding on the aforesaid point, we, as teachers, have to devise some ways to, first of all, get students to resist the identities given by others to them, and move on to discover their “true selves”. To do that, I think it would be helpful to show them the video clips of what Jane Elliot did, as well as the following video clip.
Taught to Self Hate Video Clip
Watching Jane Eliot’s clip and the clip above will let students see that everyone’s identity is actually given by other humans and everyone actually has the power to resist it. This can be done via disbelieving what others say about them, if they think what is said of them aren’t true. Then the next step is to get students to explore what their true selves are. This can be done by getting them to reflect on the things they do in their lives, their likes and dislikes, as well as getting responses from them based on given scenarios. One scenario could be:
One day, 10 children were told not to play at Railroad X because trains will be moving via it for the day. They are advised to play at Railroad Y, which will not be used that day, instead. However, 7 children did not heed the advice and were seen playing at Railroad X, while 3 other children heeded the advice and played at Railroad Y.
You are the worker who is in charge of shifting the directions of railroad. A train is fast approaching and there is not enough time for you to warn the children. You have to decide whether to shift the track to direct the approaching train to Railroad X or Y. What would you do? Why?
Students will have to reason with themselves and justify for their decisions, and through articulating their thoughts and exchanging views with their classmates, they will be able to know more of others, as well as their own selves. Additionally, after the discussion, they can write a short paragraph or two on what they think of themselves as well as what they think of some of their classmates, based on the answers and reasons they have given. Then, they will read them out, so that everyone will have an idea of how each student perceive his/her own self and how every student is being perceived by others.
After which, students will have some idea of what they “real selves” are, and they can get to the part where they create a multimodal artefact to show to others what they think they really are. The artifact would serve a persuasive function as I have mentioned earlier, we all need others to buy into our ideology in order to successfully possess identities that we want to have.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Using Films to Teach
I just watched the film, "Crash", & I thought films are actually great tools for teachers to inculcate certain things to students. Films provide the visual imageries for students to see and probably even experience theories/concepts which verbal aspects may lack. Note how some viewers actually cry when watching films with depressing contents. It says a lot about how films affect people, doesn't it?
In this case, "Crash" is seen as a film that is apt for inculcating the issue on Racism, something which doesn't seem to bemuch of an issue here on the surface, but still pretty much an issue underneath it all. Anyway, without having the teacher to say much about it, the message of how racism can be fatal is highly likely to be imprinted in the minds of the students after they have watched this film. This is how multiliteracy comes into play in our present classrooms.
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Critical Reading in Everyday Life
In breaking the code of this print advertisement, we see that this is a print anti-smoking advertisement from Romania. It is apparent because of the written text we see at the bottom right-hand corner of the print ad – “Give up smoking” – together with the “double-A” logo that bears the word “Romania”. Besides the written text, we also see a man with a lighted cigarette in the middle of the print ad. From this, we see the interplay between the written text and the image, as they compliment/support one another in conveying a notion.
To decipher the meaning this print ad is trying to convey to its readers, we see that the print ad further reinforces its stance/message against smoking by having a written text on the bottom left-hand corner that states, “It’s called suicide because it’s your choice”. As this written text is found in this print ad, it is obvious that this written text is in relation to smoking. Thus, readers will get the idea that “choosing to smoke is suicidal”.
Note also the font style of the written texts – its typography – it is very straight and can be considered as very “standard”. This may be a way to connote the seriousness of the message this ad is trying to convey – “it is of no joke/laughing matter”.
In this case, there are 2 kinds of readers the print ad is targeting – existing smokers, and non-smokers who are considering to pick up smoking. This is interpreted based on “It’s called suicide because it’s your choice”, which can be read in two ways. One way is that the sentence is meant for existing smokers who made the choice to continue to smoke; while the sentence can also be seen as a warning to non-smokers who are thinking of smoking that they are actually making a choice to die if they choose to pick up smoking.
The suicidal notion is further enhanced by the man at the centre of the print ad, which is the most salient figure in the ad, as we see him with a lighted cigarette, and he is at a position in which it seems he is actually being hung by the cigarette. The limpness of his body also creates the impression that he is already dead. Hence, here again, we see how the image and the written text enhance each other to generate more impact in conveying an idea to the readers.
In addition, the gloomy surrounding of the print ad creates a foreboding atmosphere, thus, making the act or the idea of smoking as something which is of a serious threat to anyone who picks up smoking.
Looking at the aforementioned so far, we can safely conclude that the print ad is trying to get its readers to do something after seeing this ad – to stave off smoking.
Taking up the role as a text analyst, we see that the target readers are firstly subjected to a subordinate position, as we see the written texts on both bottom corners are generally in declaratives. The idea of declarative sentences, in this case, means that the advertiser has more knowledge over the readers as the print ad is providing knowledge/information to the readers (which the readers presumably have no idea of) – through stating that smoking is suicidal and that there is a service helpline for readers to dial should they want to quit smoking or know more about giving up smoking.
The ad also interestingly tries to place the readers as someone who is witnessing the man being hung by smoking as the position/angle of the ad creates the impression that the reader is in the room, standing right in front of this man in the ad. This, in a way, produces more impact for the readers as a sense of solidarity is established in this sense. As solidarity is established, it is deemed that the readers will be more likely to heed whatever advice the ad is giving.
It is interesting to note how only a man is placed in the picture, which brings to the thought of whether this ad is only targeting at male smokers. Or is there a sense of sexism at play here with the exclusion of a female smoker? Is a man representative of both male and female smokers? This is something that is worth a thought.
In teaching a local class of Secondary 2 students, I would form the students into mini-groups of about 4 people per group. The print ad will be provided to them and some questions would be posed to them for discussion:
1. What is this print ad about? How do you know?
2. What kind of mood does the ad convey to you? Why do you get that kind of mood?
3. How does the man at the centre of the print ad help convey the message the print ad is trying to convey? Is it effective?
4. Do you think we would know what the print ad is trying to convey if there are no words in it? Why/Why not?
5. What kind of function do the words have in this ad?
6. Will there be a change of impact the ad gives if there is no image, with only the written texts? Why/Why not?
7. What kind of functions does the image have in this ad?
8. How does lighting/colour function in this ad?
9. Why is the smoker in the ad a guy?
These questions will be addressed as a class when the students are done discussing amongst themselves.
To address Question 4 & 5, students would be given another piece of the same print ad, without the written texts. This will allow the students to see how the print ad “changes” without any written text.
To address Question 6 & 7, students will be asked to write down the texts on a blank piece of A-4 size sheet, and think about whether the impact of the ad has changed, without any image on it.
In fact, for every question posed to the students, the teacher can actually them to execute it by doodling on blank sheets, so that they can see for themselves how each element in the print ad helps to enhance in the conveyance of the message intended by the ad. The teacher could also pose a question like, what difference would it make if the room in this ad is well lit & neat? Would it make a difference? Why/Why not? This is to get students to think about the reasons behind everything they see in the print ad.
Sunday, February 15, 2009
In Response to Gee & Gutierrez et al's Concepts
How might these help us to think differently about language/literacy education as you understand it? What might some of the practical classroom implications be?
When we talk about the concepts Dominant Discourse and Primary & Secondary Discourse, we have to look at not only from our own point of view, but also that of the people around us. What I mean by that is that from our point of view – supposedly educated people who are currently undergraduates – we tend to think that the dominant discourse in our society is generally Standard English, Mandarin, Malay & Tamil. By thinking so, we have actually chosen to ignore what may be going on within the actual society itself. By this, I mean to say whatever is valued by the “society” may not necessarily represent the society’s values, as it may only be the values of a dominant group – which this group subjects the values to the subordinate groups – pretty much the act of hegemony in this case.
Moving the aforesaid into something more specific – let us just say that the people at the “top tier of the social class” sees the dominant discourse as Standard English, Mandarin, Malay & Tamil in Singapore. The people who are not at the “top tier of the social class”, however, might see the colloquial version of the aforesaid four languages as the dominant discourse. There are, in fact, a number of articles on the Straits Times (Singapore Official English Newspapers) which state that Singlish should not be seen as a language that is ungrammatical and be frowned upon. On another occasion, a returning-teacher actually told me how one of her students in her form class naturally speaks Standard English, but was deemed as being pompous & was thus ostracised by the rest of the class. The abovementioned, hence, show us how subjective dominant discourse is, as it might vary on different contexts, occasions & groups of people. Will it be deemed as natural & desirable if one were to speak in Standard English, Mandarin, Malay or Tamil when conversing with stall owners in a wet market, or, hawkers in a hawker food centre? Is that the dominant discourse in those cases?
Bearing what is said above in mind, I think the Singapore educational system is trying to socialise students into what the dominant group deems as dominant discourse in the society, while disregarding whatever is considered as dominant discourse to the students themselves. This, to me, seems to be an undesirable act as the teachers are generally telling the students that what they possess currently is flawed & deemed deficient, which is in line with the language-deficit hypothesis according to Basil Bernstein, & that these students ought to learn what is considered acceptable by the society instead.
In this case, I think teachers should adopt William Labov’s theory of language-difference hypothesis, in which it states that languages are seen as different, & that no language is to be seen as being inferior to another. As such, as teachers, we should inform the students regarding how the different varieties of a language are considered apt to be used in different occasions & contexts. In this way, we are telling students that there are actually more than one dominant discourse; and they vary in different contexts & situations. Thus, students can see that in school, the teachers are only teaching them one of the dominant discourses, the Standard English, so that they can use it whenever the occasion calls for it. With that, students who do not already possess the ability to speak Standard English will not be made to feel that they are suffering from deficiency as compared to others who have been speaking Standard English at home.
Thus, the concept of hybridity is very important. Teachers can incorporate the kinds of language the students already acquired at home to teach them what is needed to be taught – in our case, Standard English language. While doing so, the teachers are also roping in the students’ home cultures & backgrounds. This forms a sense of familiarity to the students while learning Standard English, & they will be able to feel motivated to learn whatever is taught to them without feeling insecure.

